Pumpkin Pie with Salted Molasses Créme Fraîche /// Let’s make Pumpkin Puree from Scratch



 Think caramel is the only sweet topping you can salt? Think again. Imagine this salted molasses as the darker-spicier-brunette sister to the blondie we know as salted caramel. It also has that addicting sweet / salty flavor profile but with a bit of a richer flavor. I’m really not sure why caramel gets all the attention and why we don’t salt more sweet syrups. Why not salted honey? salted molasses? salted date syrup? Salted agave nectar? Based on how this pie tasted…I think I’m on to something here.




Besides the salted molasses, the other secret ingredient that really sets this pie apart is the use of vanilla beans. Vanilla extract is great when you want to infuse your baked goods but there is nothing better than speckles of fresh vanilla seeds. I stuck them in both the custard filling and in the molasses drizzle. If your local grocery store doesn’t carry vanilla beans (I know many don’t – shame on them!) then I highly suggest hopping over to J. R. Watkin’s site and picking up some of theirs. They were kind enough to send me some samples a few weeks back and I was legitimately blown away. I’m the kind of person who usually buys the beans in bulk and these beans put all of those to shame. These beans were some of the freshest I’ve ever baked with (and I, weirdly enough, have a lot of experience baking with vanilla beans. Check out here and here and here and here and here and here for written proof of it).




Let’s talk about making pumpkin puree from scratch (ie from a real sugar pumpkin, not from that can you’ve had sitting in your cabinet since last October). Have you ever made your own pumpkin puree? Come on, you can be honest with me. I’ll be honest with you – this was my first time ever making it. It’s so easy to pick up a can around this time of year that we often forget where the puree inside actually comes from.

So, here is what you really want to know: was it worth it? Well, to be completely honest, this pumpkin pie was pretty damn good. Like oh-my-god-this-pie-is-so-good-I-feel-like-I-haven’t-had-pumpkin-pie-in-a-year—oh-wait-I-haven’t good. But again, if we are being honest (which we are, remember?) then when have you ever had bad pumpkin pie?! With enough all-spice and cinnamon, any pie will taste amazing after being deprived of it for a year. So, with that truth in front of us – where does that leave making pumpkin puree from scratch? Well, here are my thoughts (because, I know you asked):


+ If you are going organic, then it’s most likely cheaper than buying the canned stuff. I spent $2.50 on this sugar pumpkin but the organic canned pumpkin was $4.00 per a can.

+ If you compare this to making a fruit pie, the roasting time probably takes about as long as it does to core, peel, and slice all those apples and/or pears. Plus, you can easily prepare the rest of the ingredient / crust while it’s roasting in the oven.

+ Since you have to let the dough chill for an hour, making a pie is time consuming regardless.  So why not have the pumpkin roasting while you wait?


– More dishes (BLAH)

– An extra step in an already lengthy recipe



So, I guess what I am saying is that you should most certainly make the puree from scratch if you have the time / energy. However, don’t feel guilty about using that canned stuff if it’s the sole factor between you making this pie or heading to the bakery section of your grocery store (most likely, in your PJs) to pick up one of theirs. Making festive treats is fun and you should remind yourself of that when diving into this; do whatever suits your effort level so that you can eventually get to the end result: eating pie. No, no. Eating lots and lots of pie. Easy.


***Please note: there are a couple ingredients (salt, sugar, etc) listed twice down below in the ingredient section. I did this because I wanted to group the different parts together (dough, filling, drizzle, etc) so that you could skip around if, for examaple, you wanted to use your grandma’s legendary pie crust instead of the one listed or if you wanted to make just the drizzle to devour over pancakes. Easy? Easy.***



Pumpkin Pie with Salted Molasses Créme Fraîche

makes 1 8 inch round pie (I used my 13×4 inch pan but feel free to use whatever you’ve got on hand) / Roasting technique courtesy of Smitten Kitchen
  • 1 1/4 cups all purpose flour
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 1/2 teaspoon sugar
  • 1 stick (1/2 cup) butter, chilled
  • 1/4 cup ice water
  • 1 medium size sugar pumpkin (or 2 cups from a can of pumpkin puree)
  • 1 Tablespoon of olive oil
  • 3 eggs, lightly beaten
  • 1/2 cup heavy cream
  • 1/2 cup sugar
  • 1 Tablespoon molasses
  • 1 vanilla bean, seeds removed and pod discarded
  • 1/2 teaspoon ground all spice
  • 1/4 teaspoon ground nutmeg
  • 1/2 teaspoons ground cinnamon
  • 1/2 teaspoons ground ginger
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt (in addition to the salt listed above)


  • 1/2 cup Créme Fraîche
  • 1 Tablespoon molasses
  • 1 vanilla bean, seeds removed and pod discarded (in addition to the bean listed above)
  • Sea Salt, to taste


If making the puree (if not, skip down to the next paragraph): Preheat oven to 400 degrees. Slice the sugar pumpkin in half and scoop out all the seeds / slimy pulp. Rub the pumpkins with olive oil and place on a cooking sheet. Roast for 40 minutes or until completely soft. Scoop out the insides into a blender and puree until smooth. Set aside and let cool.

To make the dough: Whisk together the flour, salt, and sugar. Use your clean hands to work the butter into the dry ingredients until it resembles coarse meal. Slowly, adding a tablespoon at a a time, add in the water (you may not need all of it!) until a thick, compact dough as formed. Wrap dough in plastic wrap and stick in the fridge for an hour to chill.

Preheat oven to 375 degrees (or turn it down from 400 if still on from roasting). Roll out dough on a floured work surface until it’s large enough to fit around your pan and fit the dough snuggly in a greased pie pan. Eat the leftover dough (oh, wait. Don’t do that).

To make the filling: Whisk together the sugar and molasses until a dark brown sugar forms (brown sugar!). Next, whisk in the cooled pumpkin puree, heavy cream, eggs, salt, spices, and vanilla beans until everything is combined. Pour over your pie crust in pie pan. Bake for 50 minutes or until the custard has set. Finally, remove from oven and let cool completely before cutting into.

To make the drizzle: whisk together the Créme Fraîche, molasses, and vanilla beans. Drizzle over cooled pie and sprinkle with a few big chunks of sea salt.





  • Sandra
    October 7, 2013

    Now every time I see pumpkin pie I’m going to be thinking about this one! Oh what I would give for a slice of this pie.

  • Gabby @ the veggie nook
    October 8, 2013

    This is simply beautiful! I am truly envious of your friends and family and all the good food you must share 😉

  • Nancy @ gottagetbaked
    October 9, 2013

    There is so much beauty in your photos, I can’t get over it. I love this post and recipe. I’m so lazy that I’ll probably never get around to making my own pumpkin puree, although I like to think that one day I’ll attempt it 😉

  • Dina
    October 9, 2013

    delish variation of pumpkin pie!

  • maria | pink patisserie
    October 9, 2013

    oh my goodness, you are a genius! Salted Molasses? That is brilliant! And I agree with you about the others syrups, love that idea. What a lovely dessert I ashamed to say I’ve never roasted my own pumpkin.. Must fix that..

  • Harriet
    October 10, 2013

    I wish it were autumn here! This looks frickin’ amazing! Pumpkin and pumpkin spices AND molasses?! Genius, pure and simple.

  • Grace @ earthy feast
    October 10, 2013

    This is beyond beautiful. Your pictures are stunning and the recipe looks absolutely fantastic.

  • Kris
    October 10, 2013

    Shelly, this tart looks unbelievable!! Your photos are stunning (as always) and I’m thrilled that you made your own pumpkin puree. Kudos, big time. I’m definitely going to make it in the near future.

  • Kyrie
    October 10, 2013

    This looks so nice! I am planning to make it this weekend, and I have a question: what makes the molasses salted? Is this something that happens when mixed with creme fraiche? Is there salt missing in the list? I love salted caramel so I would really like to make this the right way!
    Thank you!

    • Shellywest
      October 11, 2013

      Oh! Salt might be pretty important for Salted Molasses – hah! I topped the drizzle at the very end up a few big sea salt flakes (and have now added it to the recipe above – thanks so much for catching! how embarrassing!). Enjoy!

  • Sylvie@GitK
    October 11, 2013

    What a sensational pie. And I couldn’t agree more, let’s salt more than just caramel, here’s to a pinch of salt on everything!

  • Chung-Ah | Damn Delicious
    October 11, 2013

    This just made my Thanksgiving menu!

  • Karina
    October 12, 2013

    Hi! There’s no créme fraîche where I live, what do you think I could use instead to keep the flavor as similar as possible?

    • Shellywest
      October 12, 2013

      I’m thinking either mascarpone (it’s super easy to make your own if they don’t have it where you live! I have a recipe in my archives) or whipped cream cheese which can be thinned out with a little milk or extra molasses. Hope that helps!

    • Lindsay
      October 13, 2013

      Hi! Creme Fraiche is just sour cream with a little whipping cream mixed in, it is basically just thinned out sour cream.

      • Shellywest
        October 13, 2013

        OH! Well that is even easier! Thanks so much for the tip, Lindsay! I had no idea…

        • Karina
          November 5, 2013

          Thank you both!! It’s great when someone actually takes time to answer, really nice!

  • Sweet & Salty Curry Molasses Popcorn |
    October 14, 2013

    […] and drinks whipped up for everyone to enjoy. Although I wish I had hours and hours to spend making pies and sangria, we host the movie nights on Wednesday so I work all day. That means I have about 45 […]

  • Alanna {The Bojon Gourmet}
    November 2, 2013

    Oh my goodness, this tart is just exquisite! The topping is so beautiful, and the flavors sound incredible together. I’m loving the rectangular tart pan, too!

  • On Being Vegetarian + A Giveaway! |
    December 6, 2013

    […] of my favorite spice grinders. Do you remember when I did a shout out to JR Watkins during that Pumpkin Pie with Salted Molasses post (pictured above)? Well I’m obviously a huge fan of their spices and they were kind enough to […]

  • Spotlight on a Meme – Pumpkin Pie #49 | Barking up the Muse Tree
    April 17, 2014

    […] Pumpkin Pie with Salted Molasses Créme Fraîche /// Let’s make Pumpkin Puree from Scratch […]

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.